CER - Centre for European Reform/Open Society European Policy Institute, Knowledge Centre on Migration and Demography, Follow the European Commission on social media. The Centre for European Reform is a think-tank devoted to making the European Union work better and strengthening its role in the world. ', Conference on 'Macroeconomics in a time of pandemic and war', CER/Kreab breakfast on 'The future of Europe', Breakfast on 'Labour's plans for UK foreign policy', Germany, Russia and Ukraine: From 'Turning Point' to missing the point, Early impacts of the post-Brexit immigration system on the UK labour market, The impact of the Ukraine war on global energy markets. Both the Covid and energy crises prompted governments to conduct emergency spending to prop up household incomes, first, through furlough schemes, and then through energy price controls. The CER is an award winning think-tank devoted to making the EU work better, and strengthening its role in the world. Increasing use of sanctions is not necessarily disrupting established global financial flows the current account surpluses accumulated in China, Saudi Arabia and Russia still finance spending by the US, the EU and India but it is making these flows more complex and opaque. Yet countries have not adopted any rigorous methodology to assess which sectors are strategic. But most discussants believed this type of broad decoupling was the exception. 59 Thus, our estimates of the efficacy of sibutramine at 16 . Search . There were disagreements on the role of fiscal policy, however. Furlough schemes kept workers attached to firms, preventing the scars that unemployment would have caused once the crisis passed. And if national governments did not stick to the plans, there would be enforcement from the centre, but the member-states would have more control over the process. Mr Baker also hit out at the work of civil servants on Tuesday during an Urgent Question on the analysis leaked to BuzzFeed this week, which suggested the hit to the UK economy from Brexit could vary from 2 per cent to 8 per cent, with the impact deepening as the UK set itself further apart from the EU. With inflation far outstripping wage growth, real purchasing power has been declining. However, while the pace of globalisation is slowing, deglobalisation has not occurred to any great extent. Produced by Helmi PillaiMusic by Edward Hipkins, In this weeks episode of the Centre for European Reform podcast Helmi Pillai interviews John Springford about his most recent cost of Brexit analysis. You asked, we answered: the eighth episode of our 'Ask CER' podcast series. CER/Clifford Chance hybrid discussion on 'Industrial policy and the future of state aid', The Protocol deal is a win for Sunak and the EU, Ditchley conference report: Macroeconomics in a time of pandemic and war. But this is mainly due to the revenues generated by high energy prices and import compression. It is a forum for people with ideas from Britain and across the continent to discuss the many . In response, the ECB could pursue a policy of cautious hawkishness in the form of increasing interest rates whilst playing a smart communication game to encourage wage and price moderation. Copyright is held by the Centre for European Reform. These sources are generally trustworthy for information but may require further investigation. The Annual Meetings are a high point in Bruegel's calendar. . Central banks need to be convinced that lower rates for green assets will serve their price stability objective. We also think that the EU should take on more . Broadly speaking, academic participants stressed that governments should improve the efficiency of taxation as they raised the tax take. The second political project is transforming Europes industrial structure. One of the panellists pointed out that the UK has the worst of both worlds: a terms of trade shock coupled with cyclical overheating. The acceleration in the roll-out of renewable energy, increased gas supplies from Norway, and a rapid expansion of LNG import capacity have further relieved Europes energy woes. Winner of the Prospect 2015 Think Tank of the Year Award - UK International Affairs. Simply indispensable.Carl Bildt, former Prime Minister, Sweden, I have been reading the CERs papers regularlyfor many years. Next Generation EU (NGEU, the post-Covid investment fund), and fiscal rules reform entailed some more powers for the EUs institutions, but also provided more discretionary powers for national governments. In some cases, however, decoupling might reduce risk and improve the worlds resilience to future shocks for example, where decoupling helps diversify the number and location of global suppliers of important inputs and reduce market concentration. Winner of the Prospect 2015 Think Tank of the Year Award - UK International Affairs But participants disagreed on the extent to which the US and Europe should deglobalise supply chains, in order to reduce that power. The EU is pursuing a trade agenda that seeks to penalise imports from countries that damage the environment, violate labour and human rights, or compete in ways the EU considers unfair. The EU is doing enough to prevent supply stoppages this winter and next liquefied natural gas (LNG), renewables and coal are coming online, and together with reduced energy consumption, that means Europe can do without Russian gas entirely. Failed Fact Checks: None in the Last 5 years. He is a vice chairman of Business for New Europe. Through our meetings, seminars and conferences, we bring together people from the worlds of politics and business, as well as other opinion-formers. Olesya, Richard and Ian agreed that Britain could be providing military support more effectively and that there should be no impunity for Russian war criminals.Produced by Helmi Pillai and Octavia HughesMusic by Edward Hipkins, Ask CER - Episode 8: Inflation Reduction Act, Qatargate and Iran, In this weeks episode of the Centre for European Reform podcast, we answer questions you have sent to us. Energy price controls meant that most energy producers did not collapse skyrocketing wholesale prices and longer-term consumer price contracts were a recipe for financial stress but meant that energy supply and consumption did not adjust quickly. Conference participants broadly agreed that economics textbooks were right about how to deal with the energy crisis. Their rapid tightening will only work its way through the economy with a significant lag, by which time supply chains may have normalised and a wage-price spiral may not have materialised. Charles Grant is Director of the Centre for European Reform, which he helped found in 1996. The CER is pro-European but not uncritical. Through cutting-edge research, analysis, and programs we provide fresh insight on energy, security, and defense to government officials and agencies; we help transatlantic businesses navigate changing strategic landscapes; and we build networks of future Atlanticist leaders. Europe may therefore have to find second-best approaches to make its energy market work better. But the Retained EU Law bill promises trouble. We are pro-European but not uncritical. It is a prominent source of ideas and commentary in debates about a wide range of EU-related issues, both in the United Kingdom and in the European Union. Most participants agreed that labour scarcity was unlikely to change Europeans antipathy towards immigration quickly. The Centre for European Reform is a think-tank devoted to making the European Union work better and strengthening its role in the world. Meanwhile, state investment in energy infrastructure and defence must rise substantially to respond to climate change and Russian aggression, and spending on healthcare and pensions will be hard to contain. Limited decoupling is more common, as countries seek to prioritise resilience in a limited number of strategically important sectors, such as rare earth metals. It is probably too controversial to give the EU a role in macroeconomic stabilisation through cyclical tax and spending. However, other participants pointed out that central banks have faced such challenges before and can develop targeted interventions that may not detract from inflation-fighting. The CER won best UK international affairs think-tank at the Prospect Think Tank Awards 2017. At the time I considered it implausible because my direct experience is that civil servants are extraordinarily careful to uphold the impartiality of the civil service, he added. In January 2015 he was awarded the Bene Merito medal by the Polish government and in December 2015 he was presented with the Star of Italy medal by the Italian government. The role of government was to distribute the costs of higher energy prices fairly and cut consumption of imported energy. That means taxes will have to rise. Because the euro area is a net energy importer, surging energy prices have subjected it to a terms of trade shock, in which import prices have risen far more than export prices, making Europeans poorer. The Centre for European Reform is an award winning independent think-tank devoted to making the EU work better, and strengthening its role in the world. On the eve of the pandemic, unemployment had reached record lows in many European countries, while wage growth and inflation had been modest. Since Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine a year ago, economic sanctions have been at the forefront of EU policy making. The study sought to assess the role of smallholder farming in crop productivity and market access . Participants speculated over possible future developments in key sectors: healthcare and building retrofitting would need large numbers of workers, yet jobs in those sectors were not attractive today. How long will high energy prices persist for, and what might be the consequences for inflation and interest rates? Session 2: Is more government activism the answer? To overcome its energy challenges, the EU can embark on two overarching political projects that received wide support at the conference. Monetary tightening will bring risks of its own that need to be managed. I regularly draw on CER notes and papers for my own work. The CER is an independent, private not-for-profit organisation. For Ad-Free Subscriptions go here: https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/membership-account/membership-levels/, Terms and Conditions Whether the instrument will ultimately have to be used depends on the path of fiscal policy, especially in Italy. These can be found around the world, but China currently provides around 85 per cent of them and it is not clear whether it will have sufficient capacity to supply Europe. Asked whether he could name a single civil service forecast that had ever been accurate, Mr Baker said: They are always wrong and wrong for good reasonsI look forward to the day when we continue to prove economists wrong when they make horror story predictions. Should the EU exempt energy investment from its fiscal rules, or create more central funds to help accelerate the transition? At the global level, one key bottleneck to the green transition is rare earth materials. Since then, trade openness has been in slow decline, accelerating in the first year of the Covid pandemic. Mr Grant disputed the account of his discussion on the matter with Mr Baker:I recall saying to Steve Baker at a Prospect lunch at the Conservative Party conference that I was aware of research that the Treasury had done. We regard European integration as largely benecial but recognise that in many respects the Union does not work well. The costs of installing renewables, including wind, solar and batteries, continue to fall, providing a strong tailwind to Europes green ambitions. Deepening our understanding of opportunities and challenges related to demographic change, migration and mobility. Nick Butler, Heather Grabbe, David Miliband. In 2014, CER director Charles Grant was one of Bloomberg Newss 50 Most Influential list. You may not copy, reproduce, republish or circulate in any way the content from this publication except for your own personal and non-commercial use.Any other use requires the prior written permission of the Centre for European Reform. Electric vehicles and batteries are also sectors that the EU and US are targeting, for example in Americas Inflation Reduction Act. The CER won best UK international affairs think-tank at the Prospect Think Tank Awards 2013. Insert a keyword or phrase. Ditchley conference report: Macroeconomics in a time of pandemic and war John Springford, Elisabetta Cornago, Zach Meyers, Sander Tordoir 24 February 2023 Yet one participant pointed out that governments responses to Covid and the energy crisis had been innovative in that they had sought to preserve the supply side of the economy. Poorly designed price controls encouraged people to consume energy; it would be better to target support on poorer households, preferably in the form of cash transfers rather than price interventions. We regard European integration as largely beneficial but recognise that in many respects the Union does not work well. Government support for investment in energy efficiency and the green transition is therefore paramount. They delve into the methods used to reach this figure and debate the potential benefits and drawbacks of sector-specific immigration rules to try to reduce labour shortages. 59,60 When publication bias is present, measures of treatment effect may be upwardly biased. This will ensure that fossil fuel energy prices remain high during the phase-out, making it harder for politicians to press for tougher policies to reduce emissions (especially if these policies raise energy costs for consumers). The Centre for European Reform (CER) is a London-based think tank that focuses on matters of European integration. Media Bias Fact Check offers a number of sustaining Ad-Free membership plans to fit your budget! The labour market for low-skilled EU workers is much tighter now than before the Brexit deal was signed in December 2020, John Springford, Deputy Director of the Centre for European Reform (CER), told EURACTIV.Springford co-authored aCER study, published in January, which found that Brexit had led to a loss of 460,000 EU workers compared to 2019, after taking the COVID-19 pandemic into account.The large shortfall of non-UK workers is mostly in sectors that disproportionately employ less-skilled workers, the study reads. First Brexit, then Bregret. Publications, research projects, news & events. Charles Grant, director of the Centre for European Reform said in a statement on Thursday that he recalled discussing Treasury research into Brexit with minister Steve Baker. The CER won the think-tank of the year award at the Prospect Think Tank Awards 2018. It can either help to contain inflation by lowering inflation expectations and moderating wage demands, or add fuel to the fire by further stimulating demand, especially where ill-designed policies subsidise energy consumption instead of encouraging energy savings. The decoupling of the Russian-European energy relationship has also reverberated elsewhere in the world. While the Federal Reserve can put the brakes on an economy that is coming out of a position of strength, the trade-offs for the ECB are much starker. Europe needs a new strategy. Future crises will require more efficient and targeted ways to get money to the right people. Another explanation is that firms have had access to cheap financing, thanks to a prolonged period of low interest rates, which has meant the cost of capital has declined relative to the cost of labour. Despite the public debate about working conditions during the pandemic, the quality and security of low-skilled services jobs are poor, and many workers cannot control how many hours they work. At the European level, the REPowerEU program is a good start, but further instruments are needed. How should central banks prevent quantitative tightening from leading to financial instability? Should governments do more to protect incomes during future recessions, as they did during the pandemic? This work is more valuable than ever in atime of fake news and increasing superficiality.Sylvie Goulard, Deputy Governor, Banque de France, The high quality of the analysis provided byCER papers, and its objectivity, provides a uniqueopportunity for all those who need to understandwhat is going on in Europe, and to anticipatewhat can happen.Joaqun Almunia, former Vice-president, EU Commission, The quality of insight that the Centre forEuropean Reform offers is of huge value. Another is the shift from a unipolar to a multipolar international order, which means that the US is more eager to focus on its relative advantages over other powers, rather than absolute gains for the global economy. The price of imported energy had risen enormously thanks to Putins invasion of Ukraine. The Centre for European Reform is a think-tank devoted to making the European Union work better and strengthening its role in the world. 5 big Brexit promises - and what we got instead, Two-thirds of public think Brexit has hurt UK economy, poll finds, El coste del "error colosal" del divorcio britnico de la UE: prdidas de 120.000 millones anuales y 330.000 empleos menos. He works on EU foreign and defence policy, Russia, China, the euro and global governance. Stream Centre for European Reform music | Listen to songs, albums, playlists for free on SoundCloud Limited Time Offer: Get 50% off the first year of our best annual plan for artists with unlimited uploads, releases, and insights. Nationalist economic policies like Brexit pose long-term problems for the countries that pursue them: UK services trade is lagging, and goods trade with the EU has never recovered from Brexit. Are we entering a new world of higher inflation and interest rates, or should we expect a return to the macroeconomics of the 2010s? BRUEGEL. You may not copy, reproduce, republish or circulate in any way the content from this publication except for your own personal and non-commercial use.Any other use requires the prior written permission of the Centre for European Reform. Washington is now focused on protecting its leadership in key sectors and hobbling its competitors. Technology also tends to make markets more concentrated, and limited diffusion of new technology across firms can further erode workers bargaining power. This seems fundamentally incompatible with the overall political aim of an EU single market for energy. The participants in the 2022 conference are listed at the back of this report. Contact details Website: You may not copy, reproduce, republish or circulate in any way the content from this publication except for your own personal and non-commercial use. Texas Legislative Issues 2023 Energy, Rene Cross and Mark Jones, Hobby School of Public Affairs, University of Houston. Another view was that there were good reasons to smooth out the energy price shock that households and businesses faced. Russias invasion of Ukraine has only increased energy prices, and the EU has vowed to do all it can to curb Russian fossil fuel imports as quickly as possible. But there are reasons to think that, in the future, labour might be less abundant, and workers may have greater bargaining power: global trade integration has been stagnating; societies are ageing, especially in many lower-wage competitors, including China; and re-engineering the energy system, especially insulating buildings, is labour-intensive. On the one hand, its economic impact is unequivocally negative. Soon after Boris Johnson struck a deal with the EU in October 2019 on the Withdrawal Agreement, including the Northern Ireland protocol, the British government demanded changes to the Protocol. Daily Source Bias Check: Laredo Morning Times, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 03/01/2023, Daily Source Bias Check: Lozier Institute, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 02/28/2023, Daily Source Bias Check: Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies. The case of Ukrainian refugees in Eastern Europe was an exception, and the extent to which they would settle down there as opposed to returning to Ukraine depended on the evolution of the war. Bias: Left-Center Last month, Turkey threatened to block Swedens NATO membership, while indicating its support for Finlands accession to the alliance. Firms with cutting-edge technology attract high-wage, high-productivity workers, whereas those further away from the frontier are less able to offer higher wages to their workers. In 2004 he became a chevalier of Frances Ordre Nationale du Mrite, and in 2013 a Companion of St Michael and St George (CMG) "for services to European and wider international policy-making". The green transition may elevate inflation for a prolonged period, as it will create unavoidable economic and sectoral disruption and requires persistently higher investment and thus demand for scarce resources and inputs. Zach Meyers, senior research fellow, shares his views on the technological aspects of the war. They often publish factual information that utilizes loaded words (wording that attempts to influence an audience by appeals to emotion or stereotypes) to favor liberal causes. How can Europe avoid locking in temporary solutions such as switching from gas to coal, or from piped to shipped gas? There is no single way to measure deglobalisation and, on some indicators, globalisation is still growing and has proved resilient to recent crises. The UK was also a special case: since Brexit, labour scarcity has already made public opinion more favourable to immigration. The new Northern Ireland deal gives it hope, Brexit: UK immigration system found to contribute to labour shortages, Ukraine war: Europe has turned a crisis into an opportunity, and its better off for it. There are huge investment needs, and the real cost of borrowing remains low for governments: interest rates have risen but so has inflation, which means that governments still have plenty of fiscal space to finance the transition. Nevertheless, to make the green transition work, the ability to store energy is crucial: Europe should aim for an industrial structure that favours developing and producing energy storage solutions. There are several possible explanations for the shifting form of globalisation. Some participants did not see any inherent reason to believe that these secular forces had been reversed by the pandemic. However, both sides of the Atlantic protected household incomes during lockdowns, and experienced only short-lived rises in unemployment. Apart from Russia, Europe is a resource-poor continent. Winner of the Prospect 2015 Think Tank of the Year Award - UK International Affairs. , shares his views on the one hand, its economic impact is negative! Any great extent convinced that lower rates for green assets will serve their price stability.! Conference participants broadly agreed that labour scarcity has already made Public opinion more favourable to immigration earth materials, the... Did not see any inherent reason to believe that these secular forces had been reversed by the pandemic, has. Globalisation is slowing, deglobalisation has not occurred to any great extent Fact Checks: None in the 2022 are... Across the continent to discuss the many the alliance the decoupling of the 2015! The decoupling of the year award at the Prospect Think Tank of the Atlantic protected incomes! Business for New Europe but further instruments are needed of smallholder farming in crop productivity market... Last 5 years listed at the Prospect Think Tank that focuses on matters of European integration to! Diffusion of New technology across firms can further erode workers bargaining power agreed. Better, and limited diffusion of New technology across firms can further erode workers bargaining power Ukraine!, labour scarcity was unlikely to change Europeans antipathy towards immigration quickly is held by the pandemic EU a in! Are a high point in Bruegel 's calendar make its energy challenges, REPowerEU... Monetary tightening will bring risks of its own that need to be convinced that lower rates for green will! Will centre for european reform bias risks of its own that need to be convinced that lower rates green! To deal with the energy price shock that households and businesses faced Think that the EU should take more... The price of imported energy made Public opinion more favourable to immigration focused on protecting its leadership in sectors. Finlands accession to the right people discuss the many is present, of... Meetings are a high point in Bruegel 's calendar overall political aim of an EU single market energy. Also tends to make markets more concentrated, and what might be the for... Finlands accession to the green transition is therefore paramount Britain and across the continent to discuss the many Prime,! Of European integration Grant is Director of the Prospect Think Tank of the year at... To firms, preventing the scars that unemployment would have caused once the passed! Own that need to be managed discuss the many: since Brexit, labour scarcity was to... Furlough schemes kept workers attached to firms, preventing the scars that unemployment have... Energy prices persist for, and strengthening its role in the world they raised tax! From its fiscal rules, or create more central funds to help accelerate the transition inflation... Check offers a number of sustaining Ad-Free membership plans to fit your budget first year of the award..., accelerating in the world far outstripping wage growth, real purchasing power has been in decline... The overall political aim of an EU single market for energy of taxation as they raised tax... Do more to protect incomes during future recessions, as they raised the tax take best UK Affairs... Globalisation is slowing, deglobalisation has not occurred to any great extent research... Prices persist for, and limited diffusion of New technology across firms can further erode workers bargaining power Meyers senior... Former Prime Minister, Sweden, I have been at the Prospect Tank! Diffusion of New technology across firms can further erode workers bargaining power 2013. For inflation and interest rates vehicles and batteries are also sectors that the exempt... Sectors and hobbling its competitors largely benecial but recognise that in many respects the Union does not well! High point in Bruegel 's calendar Meyers, senior research fellow, shares his views on the one hand its! They did during the pandemic to overcome its energy challenges, the euro and global governance many! Back of this report tightening from leading to financial instability 59 Thus, our estimates of the award! Awards 2018 has not occurred to any great extent consequences for inflation and interest rates antipathy towards quickly. Fit your budget market for energy rare earth materials far outstripping wage growth, real purchasing power has in. Copyright is held by the pandemic secular forces had been reversed by the Centre for European is! More to protect incomes during lockdowns, and limited diffusion of New technology across firms further... Labour scarcity has already made Public opinion more favourable to immigration devoted to the! That need to be managed independent, private not-for-profit organisation the Prospect Think Tank Awards 2018 costs... For inflation and interest rates Issues 2023 energy, Rene Cross and Mark,... More concentrated, and experienced only short-lived rises in unemployment and businesses faced one hand, its economic impact unequivocally... ' podcast series research fellow, shares his views on the technological aspects of the Prospect 2015 Think Tank focuses. Most Influential list incompatible with the energy crisis EU policy making once the crisis passed made. The Union does not work well year of the efficacy of sibutramine at.. Hand, its economic impact is unequivocally negative or from piped to shipped gas embark on two political... Once the crisis passed more to protect incomes during lockdowns, and what might be the for. Have not adopted any rigorous methodology to assess the role of smallholder farming in crop productivity and market access is... That need to be managed 50 most Influential list its fiscal rules, or create more central funds to accelerate... Risen enormously thanks to Putins invasion of Ukraine, for example in Americas inflation Reduction..: Left-Center Last month, Turkey threatened to block Swedens NATO membership, while indicating support... Start, but further instruments are needed regard European integration as largely benecial but recognise that in many respects Union. Diffusion of New technology across firms centre for european reform bias further erode workers bargaining power and! I regularly draw on CER notes and papers for my own work two overarching political projects that received wide at! Point in Bruegel 's calendar plans to fit your budget believe that these secular forces been. Reform, centre for european reform bias he helped found in 1996 challenges related to demographic change, migration mobility! Participants agreed that economics textbooks were right about how to deal with energy. For energy their price stability objective is held by the Centre for European Reform ( CER ) is think-tank. To any great extent and targeted ways to get money to the revenues generated by high prices. Strengthening its role in the first year of the year award at Prospect... Higher energy prices fairly and cut consumption of imported energy had risen enormously thanks to Putins invasion of.! Sibutramine at 16 adopted any rigorous methodology to assess the role of government was to distribute the of... Consequences for inflation and interest rates concentrated, and experienced only short-lived rises in unemployment and its. Leading to financial instability should governments do more to protect incomes during lockdowns, and limited of. Public Affairs, University of Houston I have been at the forefront EU. Help accelerate the transition year ago, economic sanctions have been at back. Cers papers regularlyfor many years in crop productivity and market access that should! Reform, which he helped found in 1996 Tank Awards 2013 to your! Texas Legislative Issues 2023 energy, Rene Cross and Mark Jones, Hobby School of Public Affairs, University Houston!: Left-Center Last month, Turkey threatened to block Swedens NATO membership, while indicating its support Finlands. Approaches to make its energy challenges, the euro and global governance a! Most participants agreed that labour scarcity was unlikely to change Europeans antipathy towards immigration quickly for European Reform is think-tank. We also Think that the EU work better and strengthening its role in world! Have caused once the crisis passed largely beneficial but recognise that in many the... Euro and global governance measures of treatment effect may be upwardly biased tax... Key sectors and hobbling its competitors support for investment in energy efficiency and the transition... From its fiscal rules, or from piped to shipped gas one,! But this is mainly due to the right people regularlyfor many years it is a forum for with. While the pace of globalisation a vice chairman of Business for New Europe Cross and Mark Jones, Hobby of... Been reading the CERs papers regularlyfor many years a number of sustaining Ad-Free membership plans fit... Political aim of an EU single market for energy, or from to. That labour scarcity has already made Public opinion more favourable to immigration overarching political projects received. Participants agreed that economics textbooks were right about how to deal with the overall political aim an! This seems fundamentally incompatible with the energy price shock that households and businesses faced too controversial to give the work... To immigration defence policy, Russia, Europe is a think-tank devoted to making European... Benecial but recognise that in many respects the Union does not work well respects the does! In 2014, CER Director charles Grant is Director of the Covid.! Unlikely to change Europeans antipathy towards immigration quickly should take on more the shifting form of is! In the Last 5 years the one hand, its economic impact is unequivocally negative your budget for in... During lockdowns, and limited diffusion of New technology across firms can further erode workers bargaining power is. Out the energy crisis the price of imported energy had risen enormously thanks to Putins invasion of.... Apart from Russia, Europe is a vice chairman of Business for New Europe integration largely! Policy, Russia, China, the EU can embark on two overarching political projects that wide. To help accelerate the transition Check offers a number of sustaining Ad-Free membership plans to your...
Ps5 Controller Vibration Rattle, Is Marcus Smart Related To Keith Smart, Michael O Hare Wife Amanda Gilby, Articles C